In 2011, my beloved miniature pinscher Bucky died very suddenly. He had been my soul mate and my psychiatric service dog. Because of my grief, I was unable to leave the house.
Another writer, my friend Carle, decided to help me through this process. I was obsessed with the television show starring Hugh Laurie, "House M.D," about a misanthropic, brilliant, crippled doctor. Carle downloaded the first 5 seasons. Within a few episodes, he was as obsessed as I was. This blog is the correspondence we conducted, episode by episode. With a few digressions.
Carle's entries are in black; my contributions are in blue.
Two obsessed writers discussing, deconstructing and quarreling about the television show "House M.D.".
Introduction To This Blog
Introduction To This Blog
Monday, April 28, 2014
Season One, Episodes 3 & 4: Occam's Razor and Maternity
Description:(Occam's Razor)
After
calling in sick at work, 22-year-old college student Brandon (Kevin
Zegers) spends the morning having wild sex with his fiancee--and then
lapses into unconsciousness. It's obvious to Dr. House (Hugh Laurie)
that Brandon wasn't lying about being sick, but his symptoms are
mysterious and contradictory--and worse, they keep multiplying. As he
tries to figure out this puzzle, House saves time by treating all of his
other patients in a record five minutes.
this is a gimme. Occam's Razor first
became popularized via the jodie foster film "contact" from the book
by carl sagan. since then, it has become the 'go-to' concept used by everyone
as shorthand for critical thinking, and because it sounds sooo cool...which is
part and parcel of the essence of this particular episode: teenage sex! yes,
starts off with a bang! and why? so the cute F asst. can tease the cute M asst.
with saucy asides as she thrust out her prodigious headlamps at him in the
lounge. and, as well, the whole 'defiance-in-the-face-of-authority' thang gets
the patient a full body scan and medical just because house identifies with her
attitude. see? it pays to be cool!
ok. i'll bite. who IS Wilson? seems to be an
administrator who's always around but doesn't work for the uber-she.
Description: Maternity
After
checking on two neonatal infants who have suffered mysterious seizures,
House (Hugh Laurie) concludes that the clinic has become the breeding
ground for a deadly epidemic--which is rapidly spreading to the other
newborns. In order to isolate the reason for this outbreak and to stop
it in its tracks, House is faced with a difficult choice: One of the
babies will have to die to save the others. As it turns out, the source
of the epidemic has little to do with babies, but neither House nor the
audience finds this out until the very last moment
Maternity. you know, when i think about the
Paternity episode, i think it really ought to have been called, Parenting,
because it didn't have anything to do with a paternity suit and the fact that
the kid was adopted makes it more about a 'family matter' than anything having
to do with who was the sire and who was the dam...and who is the parasite.
which may have been the major point of this ep, as house gets to show his
contempt for children as well. as for the treatment? no way. never in 1000yrs.
this is the stuff that trial lawyers' dreams are made of. sorry, uh-uh.
violates credibility
so, why is he in the maternity lounge? to watch
the TV? he doesn't seem to mind watching his portable, so why would he change
his habits? as you know, habits aren't hard to break, they're fucking
impossible to break--they can only be substituted for or curbed, but only with FULL
SELF-KNOWLEDGE! and he doesn't ever make a comment that his M asst., the blonde
guy, is a dead ringer for the one on GH?
#####################################################
#####################################################
Wow,
you're getting obsessed! I STILL cannot believe you are watching
every episode of this show from the beginning. Once you burn out,
I'll give you a list of the particularly good episodes. Bear in mind that
in the first season they're still working out the kinks.
Remember,
this is television, not reality, so there's a lot of shorthand. Also, the
titles usually mean several different levels (maybe not Occam's Razor, but it
became standard later on and gave the analysis monkeys something to
dissect). The reality is that a real hospital would NEVER keep a doctor
like House for more than three weeks. But this character is the springboard for
1,000 snarky main characters. Check out:
This
site...well, you have to see for yourself. I think you will really,
really like it and not just because of the show. The
beginning of the shows are called "teasers" for a reason. Last
season and this season have had overreaching teasers that strain credulity to
the breaking point. What's a gimme?
catchall
for 'been-there/done that' etc. simply that any episode with that title is
going to be a cultural hitchhike upon the fender skirts of greater minds...
Wilson's
character didn't really come together until Season Two. He's the head of
oncology but who seems to have plenty of time to hang around House and his
crew. Last season they did an episode called "Wilson" in which
they explored his day, more or less. The parts involving House's team was
pretty funny, because you saw how completely insane it looks from the outside.
Wilson both works for the uber-she, but also conspires with her to control
House.
so, why is he in the maternity lounge? to watch
the tv? he doesn't
seem to mind watching his portable, so why would he change his habits?
as you know, habits aren't hard to break, they're fucking impossible
to break--they can only be substituted for or curbed, but only with
FULL SELF-KNOWLEDGE!
seem to mind watching his portable, so why would he change his habits?
as you know, habits aren't hard to break, they're fucking impossible
to break--they can only be substituted for or curbed, but only with
FULL SELF-KNOWLEDGE!
House will do ANYTHING to keep from being bored.
Everything is a substitute for his basic addiction: medicine. Without
medicine he is nothing. Well, he's a drug addict, too. Pills, video
games, television...as for the latter, House watches it all over the
hospital as long as he can be left alone. Mostly in the wing where the
coma patients are. For the medical, etc., you should check a great site,
"Polite Dissent," in which a doctor analyzes the medicine in each
episode. There are several doctors on the staff, but still, the show plays fast
and loose. This show in some ways is as formulaic as "Law And
Order"; patient shows up, the staff nearly kills him a few times before
finding the disease--although sometimes they die.
no way. never in 1000yrs. this is the stuff that trial lawyers' dreams are made of. sorry, uh-uh. violates credibility
As I wrote earlier, in real life House would never sustain employment. But this is a tv show called "House, MD," so...
right.
answers the above. understood. this is "medical lite" like law&order is "legal lite". so the idea is to ignore the contrivances [after all, this is listed as a mystery] and concentrate on adapting the acerbic comments to any public discourse i might engage in, yes?no way. never in 1000yrs. this is the stuff that trial lawyers' dreams are made of. sorry, uh-uh. violates credibility
As I wrote earlier, in real life House would never sustain employment. But this is a tv show called "House, MD," so...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment